Pros and Cons of SEO in the AI Era
Much as I love SEO (and I do!), it isn’t necessarily the best marketing strategy for every business. Shock horror!
And unlike some other industry professionals, I’ll openly tell you that in your free SEO Checkup!

That said, when SEO (Search Engine Optimisation) is the right fit, it can be one of the most powerful long-term marketing investments you’ll make.
So, what are the pros and cons of SEO in today’s AI-driven world?
As an SEO expert of close to 15 years’ experience, I’m constantly researching this ever-evolving beast. Here are some of my insights …
The Pros of SEO: Why It’s Still Worth It
Results that Go the Distance: One of the biggest advantages of SEO is its longevity. Unlike paid ads that stop generating enquiries the moment your budget dries up, strong SEO can generate leads for years.
In fact, we’re still seeing top positions for keywords targeted 5+ years ago – which are generating enquiries – on this very website, as well as client campaigns! 😮
A Fresh Flow of Right Place, Right Time Buyers: SEO opens the door to an entirely new stream of potential customers. You’re not interrupting people – you’re showing up exactly when they’re searching for what you offer.
That’s why SEO traffic tends to convert so well. These are high-intent leads who already want your service.
This is also why optimising your website for relevant keywords and topics is so important!
Traffic Without the Ad Spend: And let’s not forget cost. While SEO does require an upfront investment, the traffic itself is essentially “free” once you’re ranking. No ongoing payments to Google Ads or Meta just to stay visible (hallelujah!).
‘Own’ Your Local Area: For local businesses, the benefits of local SEO are even more compelling. Showing up in Google’s map pack or having a well-optimised Google Business Profile can drive calls, bookings, and foot traffic – often without a single click through to your website (no thanks to AI overviews!).
And if you focus on ranking above your competitors here, who do you think your potential customers are going to book with first?
The Cons of SEO: What to Be Aware Of
Not an Overnight Fix: Now for the reality check: SEO takes time. So, if you’re after instant leads, this probably isn’t your strategy.
But if you can play the long game, the good news is that the results compound over time.
It’s a Moving Target: No set and forget here – SEO is an ever-changing space. Between Google updates and the rise of AI search, what worked last year (or even last week!) might need tweaking today.
And while we follow Google’s best practices and guidelines here at Front Page SEO (as any white hat SEO specialist should), unfortunately there’s no “magic formula” for success. We can only learn from experience and consistency.
Fewer Website Clicks: With Google’s AI Overviews and other answer engines, users today often get what they need without visiting your site. That’s why local SEO – specifically, optimising and regularly updating your Google Business Profile, is more important than ever.
Beware the Smoke & Mirrors: Lastly, yes – unfortunately there are still some dodgy operators out there. SEO can feel like smoke and mirrors if it’s not explained clearly, which is why transparency is something we prioritise at Front Page SEO. One recent client was really impressed with our monthly reporting – something he had never received fromhis previous agency!
So … Is SEO Still Worth It?
In my humble opinion? Absolutely – if it aligns with your business goals. Because here’s the thing: if you’re not investing in SEO, chances are your competitors are.
SEO in the AI era isn’t dead – it’s just evolving. And the businesses that lean into it now will be the ones reaping the rewards in the years to come.
Keen to get your business seen in both AI tools and Google search? Book a free SEO check-up or a one-on-one online consultation with our Brisbane SEO consultant today!























